Are Workers' Comp Experience Ratings Misused?

Tell us what you think in the comment box or by email

What seemed like a simple story has become much more complicated, and we need your help.

In 2017, the chief actuary of the main insurance industry rate-setting corporation for workers' compensation wrote that experience modification ratings (EMR) could not be relied on as an accurate pre-qualification criteria for using a contractor.

The idea wasn't new, but it got our attention.

We know that workers' compensation experience modification ratings are a reliable means to help employers improve safety. And an important precision tool in setting the workers' compensation premium for each employer. But the ratings are relied on by owners and prime contractors as a tool in evaluating a contractor's safety performance.

Although E-Mods were never designed to be used that way, contractors say that their low rating is an important method of competing.

When, if ever, should the EMR be the only measure in evaluating a contractor's safety performance? And what other measures, such as Total Recordable Injury Rate, should be given equal weight?

There are other related issues. What is the minimum amount of information needed for an accurate picture of how safe an employer really is?

Looking for quick answers on construction and engineering topics?
Try Ask ENR, our new smart AI search tool. Ask ENR →

What do the safety pre-qualifications your company completes require?

Our story on this subject will appear in April. We invite you to post comments below or to email me at kormanr@enr.com.

KEYWORDS: compensation

Deputy Editor Richard Korman helps run ENR's business and legal news and investigations, selects ENR's commentary and oversees editorial content on ENR.com. In 2023 the American Society of Business Publication Editors awarded Richard the Stephen Barr Award, the highest honor for a single feature story or investigation, for his story on the aftermath of a terrible auto crash in Kentucky in 2019, and in 2015 the American Business Media awarded him the Timothy White Award for investigations of surety fraud and workplace bullying. A member of Investigative Reporters and Editors, Richard has been a fellow on drone safety with the McGraw Center for Business Journalism at the Craig Newmark Graduate School of Journalism at CUNY. Richard's freelance writing has appeared in the Seattle Times, the New York Times, Business Week and the websites of The Atlantic and Salon.com. He admires construction projects that finish on time and budget, compensate all team members fairly and record zero fatalities or serious injuries.

Post a comment to this article

Join ENR's NY/NJ Infrastructure Forum on September 14 at Pier Sixty in NYC to hear from top public agency officials on capital plans and connect with MWBE contractors to uncover major partnership and bidding opportunities across the Northeast. Gain actionable insights to navigate regulatory uncertainty and position your firm for infrastructure success.

Join ENR’s Seattle Infrastructure Forum on October 14 at the Westin Seattle to connect with key decision-makers from Sound Transit, WSDOT, and the Port of Seattle. Gain early insight into billions in capital projects and strategic opportunities across the Puget Sound region’s booming infrastructure market.