This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
This Website Uses Cookies
By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to our cookie policy. Learn More
This website requires certain cookies to work and uses other cookies to help you have the best experience. By visiting this website, certain cookies have already been set, which you may delete and block. By closing this message or continuing to use our site, you agree to the use of cookies. Visit our updated privacy and cookie policy to learn more.
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • News
    • Newswire
  • Texas-Louisiana
  • Features
    • Projects
    • Companies
  • Top Lists
  • Current Issue
  • Blogs
  • Submit Your Photos
    • People
    • Projects
    • Events
  • Resources
    • Proposals & Bids
    • Industry Jobs
    • Subscribe
    • eNewsletter
    • Events
    • Advertise
    • Reprints and Plaques
    • Construction Cities
  • ENR Home
  • Other Regions
    • ENR Home
    • California
    • MidAtlantic
    • Midwest
    • Mountain States
    • New York
    • New England
    • Northwest
    • Southeast
    • Southwest
    • Texas & Louisiana
Home » $8.12-Million Settlement Reached in Texas Lawsuit
Texas & Louisiana Construction NewsTexas-Louisiana

$8.12-Million Settlement Reached in Texas Lawsuit

June 13, 2014
Louise Poirier
Reprints
No Comments

A lawsuit filed two years ago by Zapata County Independent School District against Houston-based Satterfield & Pontikes Construction and several subcontractors has ended with an $8.12-million settlement paid to the district.

The two elementary schools Satterfield & Pontikes built for Zapata County ISD, Zapata South Elementary School and Fidel & Andrea R. Villarreal Elementary School, opened in January 2006. Both were constructed from a $16-million bond package approved in 2003.

Six years later, in spring 2012, the school district filed a lawsuit against the design and construction team, alleging poor quality work on the two schools, as well as on covered play pavilions built at the Zapata North and Arturo L. Benavides elementary schools.

Other firms named in the suit with Satterfield & Pontikes included Alamo Controls Inc., Alamo Waterproofing Inc., Cover Painting Corp., Davis Contractors Ltd., Excel Applicators Inc., Midway Welding Inc., Twin City Glass, Romero Construction and E. Romero Construction LLC.

The lawsuit made 11 claims against the defendants, including: a failure to construct the projects in accordance with plans and specifications; failure to properly seal openings in plaster and stucco outside walls, allowing unconditioned air to enter the building and damage HVAC components of the building and case accumulation of infiltrates; substitution of materials and equipment with cheaper and lower quality materials; and a failure to construct the projects in a good and workmanlike manner.

The suit initially sought $16 million in damages from the defendants.

The trial began on January 13 and ended two weeks later, after a settlement was reached.

“The sole purpose of entering into the settlement agreement was to avoid the time, expense, uncertainty and inconvenience of continued dispute, discussion and the lawsuit,” said Juan J. Cruz of law firm J. Cruz & Associates LLC, who represented ZCISD, to ENR in a written statement. “There was no admission of liability, culpability or wrongdoing.”

However, “the entire design and construction team collectively settled through insurance, which is a lot different” than paying the settlement out of pocket, notes John Marshall, vice president at Satterfield & Pontikes.

Additionally, during the six years between the time the schools were completed and the lawsuit was filed, “we never had a single warranty call, to my knowledge,” Marshall says. “When this was first brought up, naturally the first thing that we would want to do is take a look at it and see if we could repair any issues, and instead the district decided to go a different route.”

Marshall adds, “Obviously, we’re disappointed that the matter went as far as it did, but we are happy that a settlement was reached. All throughout the course of the project and through the warranty period, we had a terrific relationship with the district, the owner, and we know we supplied a very good product—several good facilities.”

Previous 1 2 Next

ENR Subscribe

Recent Articles by Louise Poirier

UAE Plant To Grow

Texas Central Expands Its Team for High Speed Rail Job

Design, Ground Conditions Test on Austin Interchange

Louise_poirier

Louise Poirier is editor of ENR Texas & Louisiana, which covers Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Oklahoma and Texas, and ENR Southwest, which covers Arizona, Nevada and New Mexico. She joined ENR's staff in 2012 and reports from Houston.

Related Articles

Texas High-Speed Rail Project Reaches 50% Capital, Announces Design-Build Partnership

Work on $93 Million Veterinary & Biomedical Education Project Underway at Texas A&M

Ship and Oil Barge Collide in Houston Ship Channel, Spilling 168,000 Gal of Oil Into Texas Waters

Related Products

ENR Texas & Louisiana August 12, 2019 Issue

ENR Texas & Louisiana February 11, 2019 Issue

Post a comment to this article

Report Abusive Comment


Top Lists

Top Design FirmsTop Design Firms
Continued Growth Signals Positive Outlook For Region


Top ContractorsTop Contractors
Construction Continues To Boom Across The South


Top Specialty ContractorsTop Specialty Contractors
Abundant Jobs, Labor Shortages Define Regional Market



Industry Jobs

Videos
ENR Proposals and Bids


ENR twitterfeed
Tweets by ENR_TXLA

ENR

ENR December 16, 2019 cover

Dec 16, 2019

To attract a broader and more diverse workforce, companies and unions are courting the LGBTQ+ community and strengthening recruiting and retention efforts.

View More Create Account
  • Resources
    • advertise
    • contact us
    • about us
    • photo submissions
    • customer service
    • digital edition
    • Survey And Sample
  • Subscription Center
    • Subscribe
    • Website Registration
    • Privacy Policy
    • eNewsletters
    • FAQ
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Slideshows
    • Photo Contest

Copyright ©2019. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing