Metals in Construction magazine has announced the winner of its 2021 Design Challenge competition, which asked architects and engineers how they would create a new affordable-housing development at Sunnyside Yard in Queens. The competition was speculative, but its design brief was based on proposals set forth in the Sunnyside Yard Master Plan Handbook, a detailed technical guide for exploring the rail yard’s development opportunities, published in March 2020.
“Each year the magazine hosts a competition that challenges designers globally with envisioning solutions to real-world situations that respond to human needs,” says Gary Higbee, AIA, director of industry development for the Steel Institute of New York, co-publisher of the magazine and sponsor of this year’s competition. “This year’s brief drew an array of innovative approaches for capturing the space above Sunnyside Yard to create much-needed affordable housing.”
The site selected for the competition, which contemplates Phase 1 of a development plan, is located on a portion of the active rail yard between Queens Boulevard and Honeywell Street. Entrants to the competition were asked to envision a structural steel deck that would create a platform for development over the yard, adding valuable urban space to the area. Overbuilding the network of tracks has long been considered a viable way to create more public land and meet the needs of the area’s growing population.
RKD Architects, the Dublin-based winning team, presented a plan for a platform composed of a 60x60-ft structural steel grid aligned to streets on the north and west edges of the yard. The platform’s underlying framework considers different sizes and typologies of housing units, allowing them to be adapted to residents’ changing needs over time. Units can be combined, extended, or renovated within the primary building structure. The first three floors of each building block feature a mixed-use program. A central greenway spine and public square add green space to the plan.
“The competition posed many challenges, including structural, urban design, environmental and social,” says juror Jack Robbins, partner and director of urban design at FXCollaborative Architects. “The most successful entries responded on all of these fronts, and the winning proposal did so in a way that was innovative, reflected the amazing diversity of Queens, and felt like a part of the city.”
The competition’s two finalists were London-based DAAB Design Architects working with members of LERA and Buro Happold and a team from New York-based Pei Cobb Freed & Partners Architects, working with members of Guy Nordenson and Associates and Ken Smith Workshop. The full proposals from each team are available via the links below.
“The entries have shown a wide variety of approaches: it was a true reflection, in my opinion, of how architects and urban planners, along with their allies—the structural engineers and facade consultants—are looking at the challenge and seeking an opportunity to make a difference,” says competition juror Enrica Oliva, partner and COO of Werner Sobek New York. “It’s encouraging to see that the design teams are coming up with exciting solutions, and that sustainability, renewable energy and innovative technologies are put at the forefront of the designs.”
Additional competition jurors included Eli Gottlieb, managing principal of Thornton Tomasetti and Shefali H. Sanghvi, AIA, LEED AP BD+C, associate at Dattner Architects.
For more information about the winning and finalist entries and the annual competition, please visit metalsinconstruction.org.
WINNER: RKD Architects Team
Harry Browne, Paul Davey, Karolina Backman, Rebecca O’Connor, Sinead Keating, David Browne
FINALIST: “Minding the Gap” Team
Pei Cobb Freed & Partners Architects: Michael Bischoff, Alberto Montesinos, Michael Lyon, Duckjune Park, Edward Liew, Xiao Qin, Will Garris
Guy Nordenson and Associates: Guy Nordenson, Gina Morrow, Xiaoxiao Wu, Katie Kennedy
Ken Smith Workshop: Ken Smith, Hardy Stecker, Feixiong Yu
FINALIST: “Loop n Link” Team
daab design Architects: Dennis Austin, Anais Blehaut, David Hart, Dale Ratcliff, Dominika Pilch
LERA Consulting Structural Engineers: Dan Sesil, Jason Stone
Buro Happold: Denzil Gallagher, Varun Kohli, Kenton Phillips